Which Caribbean Cruising Ground Suits You
Most comparisons of Caribbean cruising grounds are written in adjectives. These are the numbers behind ours, compiled from live crewed charter availability and booking records in September 2026.
| Cruising ground | Yachts | Median week | Catamarans | Median length | Suits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| British Virgin Islands | 385 | $37,000 | 80.0% | 59 ft | First charters, families, short hops |
| U.S. Virgin Islands | 256 | $36,821 | 75.8% | 59 ft | Short weeks, no clearing in, fastest arrival |
| St. Martin and St. Barts | 228 | $48,000 | 63.6% | 67 ft | Dining, harbour towns, larger yachts |
| The Grenadines | 193 | $46,280 | 65.3% | 67 ft | Repeat charterers, distance, quiet |
If it is your first charter
Take the British Virgin Islands. The Sir Francis Drake Channel is the most forgiving water in the region, the fleet is the largest and the most catamaran heavy, and no leg of the week is long enough to test anyone. Nothing else here is this easy.
If the week is short, or the flights are awkward
Take the U.S. Virgin Islands. You board faster, you clear no customs, and at $1,214 per stateroom per night it is the least expensive ground we track. The sailing is close to the BVI because it is the same archipelago.
If the group cares where it eats
Take St. Martin and St. Barts. It costs about 30 percent more per stateroom than the Virgin Islands and asks more of the crossings, and it is the only ground here where the towns are part of the point.
If you have done this before
Take the Grenadines. The smallest fleet, the longest passages, the least development ashore, and Tobago Cays. It is the ground guests ask for on a second or third charter, rarely on a first.
And the Bahamas
We count the Bahamas separately, because it is Atlantic rather than Caribbean and behaves like a different market: 19.7 percent catamarans against 77.4 percent here, an 88.6 foot median length, and $81,000 for a median week. If the shortlist includes both, they are not variations on one holiday.





