According to Reddit, is Anegada worth the trip on a BVI charter?

According to Reddit, Anegada splits the room: one camp says “Don’t miss Anegada,” while charter pros call it the island you save for charter number two. In an r/chubbytravel thread, one sailor insists on going “all the way” (it is “the only time you will be out of sight of land”) for near-empty beaches, lobster dinners, conch mounds, and flamingos. A charter planner counters that Anegada sits almost 30 nautical miles from Jost Van Dyke, so it only earns its slot with a fast catamaran, a good forecast, and an overnight stay; rushed “as a checkbox stop,” it burns a prime sailing day in transit. The practical consensus: let the captain read the weather and decide. Weigh the detour against the rest of the BVI charter guide.