What is the safest island in the British Virgin Islands?

The safest island in the British Virgin Islands is Virgin Gorda, on both the crime and the marine-safety metrics. Crime across the BVI is low overall — the territory averages well below the Caribbean median — but Virgin Gorda has the most-developed marina infrastructure (Bitter End, Saba Rock, Spanish Town), the most-patrolled anchorages (North Sound), and the lowest reported petty-theft incidents in the BVI Tourist Board statistics. For weather safety, North Sound on Virgin Gorda is one of the most protected hurricane holes in the eastern Caribbean. Tortola is also safe, though the main town of Road Town has more reported petty incidents than the smaller islands. Anegada is remote and effectively crime-free. See BVI anchorages.